Webheader newlogo2

           Where EVERY Policy Comes With An Agent...



 "There is hardly anything in the world that some man cannot make a little worse and sell a little cheaper, and the people who consider price only are this man's lawful prey."-- John Ruskin


We are expanding!  As part of our 35 year celebration of insuring Pennsylvanians, we are proud to announce our entry into the states of Maryland and Delaware!  The DE and MD expansion is estimated to be completed around October 15th, 2015.  Visit us frequently for updates!     

If you ARE a resident of PA, DE or MD, OR are moving to one of these states and need coverage upon your arrival, you are in the right place! 

If you ARE NOT, and aren't planning on moving here in the near future Click Here to find an insurance agent in your area. Remember, this action will bypass our site, and direct you to agents in your own locale.  




 Who We Are, What We Do, and HOW We Do It.

Purchasing insurance coverage is NOT the same as making a trip to the grocery store.  However, unfortunately this is how creating an insurance program is perceived by many (and unfortunately at the hands of some insurance companies themselves through "creative" advertising). 


  • EVALUATE your current situation and insurance program
  • LISTEN to your needs and concerns
  • Attempt to UNDERSTAND those issues
  • EDUCATE you about your program, where you are, and where you need to be
  • SEARCH all of our available markets for your solutions
  • ASSIST in making a positive change to your insurance program
  • And ultimately, PROTECT you with coverages that are suitable and affordable


We are not a large agency.  And we don't profess to be all things to all people.

Our forte is providing insurance for farmers of all types, sizes, and diversifications.  And we round out our portfolio of offerings with personal lines coverages of homeowner and personal auto, small business and related lines, as well as all types of recreational vehicles, ranging from RVs to cycles and snowmobiles.  We also offer life insurance programs in all three states.

We stick with what we know best.  Our goal is to educate our clients so they are informed, have a reasonable expectation of what their insurance program can and cannot do for them, and to create it at an affordable cost.

It sounds simple, but it IS in may cases QUITE a challenge.  But that is what drives us every day to help another insured.

There is SO much more than DOLLAR COST to an insurance program.  As the old cliche goes, "cheapest is not always the best".

What's New...

We are Expanding into Delaware and Maryland!  This should be finalized by approximately October 15, 2015.  Re-visit this section for periodic updates!

We Have Moved EFFECTIVE 06-15-14: Read the Details in Our Announcement Letter

Winter '14- '15 Newsletter

  Vol 10 is now available:

Important Reminders, Info and Tips-

  • 2015 Business Operating and Holiday Schedule
  • Thank You for Your Patience During Our Move
  • PennDot "Nastygrams"- PA
  • Sump Failure & Sewer Backup Reminder- PA
  • Ramped Up Referral Program!  Refer us and have a change to win a Samsung 32" 1080p LED flat screen TV! (PA only at this time)
  • Auto Insurance Medical Expense Coordination Reminder- PA



 Winter '13- '14 Newsletter Vol 9

  • Countryway Insurance Updates:
    1. Online Bill Pay Now Available: www.countryway.com
    2. New Claims Reporting Procedure Including Auto Glass Claims
    3. EFT Still Available (Electronic Funds Transfer from Checking or Savings
    4. Barn Fire Prevention Tips
  • Important Reminder About Deleting Retained Vehicles- PA
  • Managing Rate Adjustments With Higer Deductible Options- PA
  • Misc Updates and Important Reminders- PA



Volumes 1 through 8 of our Annual Newsletter are available in our LIBRARY


Insuring CSAs (Community Supported Agriculture Farms) is our Specialty...



Brian's Insurance Blog- Periodic articles on everything from managing your insurance program to insurance industry trends and their effect on you as an insurance consumer. 

 2015 Holiday Schedule

April 3- Good Friday

May 25- Memorial Day

July 3- Independence Day Weekend

September 7- Labor Day

November 26, 27- Thanksgiving

December 21 thru Jan 3, 2016- Christmas and New Years Week

Jan 4, 2016- Normal Operating Hours Resume


Outlook Sig Graphic4

    Matthias Insurance Agency Inc


     Operating Hours:  M-F   9 am - 5 pm or by appointment

Important Note:  As of 06-15-14 we no longer maintain a walk-in office.  Face-to-face meetings are by pre-arranged appointment at a location convenient for you.  Just give us a call!



iablogoclrsmall1 iia 2color cmyk 300dp small








      Company Claims Phone Numbers 

  • Agency Insurance Company- 800-841-5241
  • American Modern-  800-375-2075
  • Assurant Health-  See your policy/Call us
  • Countryway-  800-828-6862 (8-4:30 M-F)
  • Countryway-  888-223-3649 (After hours)
  • Progressive-   800-925-2886
  • Foremost-   800-527-3907
  • Hagerty-    800-922-4050
  • Infinity-   800-334-1661
  • Rain and Hail-   Call us
  • Safeco-   800-332-3226 


Think about it...  Insurance fraud ultimately costs ALL of us more money.  It's that simple.  Go to HelpStopFraud.org to find out more.


 TIP:  Package It UP!- Insure your home/farm along with either your personal auto or farm truck policy and receive package discounts up to 15%. EASY!!!